I love to be genuinely worried about the people on stage. I love props and furniture crashing to the floor with unnerving clatter. I love repetitious, elliptical dialogue that sounds like music when the rhythms and tension are on point. I love men crying and ears bleeding and characters my heart aches for even though they are frustrating, shitty people who don’t care what I think of them. I love abject humanity revealing itself as an immutable fact I must confront.
All of these narrative kinks of mine are fully satisfied by Coal Mine Theatre’s granular, earthy production of the David Mamet classic, American Buffalo. Ken MacKenzie’s set and props, holy hell, let’s start there! It’s easy enough to cram a bunch of stuff onto a stage; it takes more strategic care to convince us that the environment has been lived in, that it’s a mid-1970s Chicago junk shop and not just artful clutter.
Director Jordan Laffrenier’s staging let’s that patina accrue on the actors too, their bodies fully in tune with the environment and each other. The story revolves around three men in a shop, desperate to claw their way out of the hole of a life they’ve sunken into. There’s stuff about coins and a heist and an assortment of shady figures on the periphery: we track these particulars, though they are only a frame for Mamet’s portrait of friendship mired in the blue-collar struggle for survival. That music I mentioned, it manifests as a cadence of familiarity and guarded masculine expression—the gruff notes convey frustration, hurt and, ultimately, affection.
The surliest amongst them is Ted Dykstra’s Teach. Oh, man, is he a piece of work! The language Mamet gives him is crass at best, outright racist and misogynistic at worst. Dykstra’s colourful portrayal bounces back and forth between smart-assery and utter exhaustion. He’s very funny too and persuades us that, even in his most vile moments, the vitriol and violence are not malicious, they’re armour.
Though it’s hard to imagine cozying up to any of them, Don is, I’d say, the easiest to share a space with, he’s certainly the one whose rough edges have been the most smoothed out. Shawn Doyle hints at both wisdom and fatigue underneath the practiced calm of this junk shopkeeper, perhaps he’s just had too many years of wasted bluster. Taking care of himself and concerned for the well-being of his underling, Bob (Mackenzie Wojcik), he espouses the value of yogurt to this obliging, painfully inarticulate young man who runs errands for him.
Written to be almost entirely monosyllabic, we wonder at Bob’s inner life. Even before the rain starts, Wojcik seems constantly damp, his stringy, unkept hair perfectly aligned with his grungy clothes. He’s genuinely affable and, whatever trouble he’s getting himself into, we believe his heart is at least in the right place. His youth does a lot of heavy lifting where our empathy is concerned, but his agitation is so palpable, it’s hard to warm to him. Wojcik is none-the-less fascinating to watch as he never quite lets on how much is landing in Bob’s fraught psyche and that ambiguity is quietly thrilling.
The rest of the design team is firing on all cylinders, though their collaborative machine isn’t drawing attention to itself. Des’ree Gray’s costumes blend into the earthy pallet of the scenic design with individual looks that say so much about how these guys exist in their neighbourhood. Teach’s leather jacket is stylish, but stained—he’s got something to prove, but he doesn’t care if its appealing to you. Don’s slacks are beat up, but his understated plaid dress shirt confirms he’s trying the hardest. And Bob—with his ill-fitted torn jeans, his grubby jacket thrown over a sweaty undershirt—he’s trying to comfortable, but is totally oblivious to how his appearance affects the attitudes toward him.
Steve Lucas’ lighting is natural and understated. The understated ambience of Olivia Wheeler’s sound design further fills out the convincing atmosphere, though the score that introduces each act is a jarring contrast. Building to an almost operatic intensity in the darkness, then cutting out suddenly just as the lights open on the shop—it’s a bold narrative tell: that the intimate ugliness on stage, the disarming verisimilitude, holds something of great value, something experientially epic, and demands we sharpen our attention for it.
And yes, it does get ugly. By the very end, though, after the ferocity and fried nerves, when we and the characters must sit with the consequences, something tender rises to surface. Mamet wasn’t being cheeky when he said this is a love story.
Shout out to fight director, David Chinchilla, and dialect coach, Diane Pitblado, for their contributions to the authenticity here.
When a production is this fucking good, when the director, designers and actors understand the material so thoroughly, embody it with such compelling honesty, a review runs the risk of reading like a tribute, as I know this does. It is what it is. A part of me is still stuck in the junk shop, with those men, and articulating that for you is a gesture of gratitude towards the astonishing craft.


