Only a month ago, in preparation for Bowtie Productions’ take on it, I finally introduced myself to the lofty landmark of the musical theatre landscape that is Pippin. I was wary because, despite finding Godspell kinda cool, my only other experience of Stephen Schwartz (music and lyrics) was Wicked. And I low-key despise Wicked. I was pretty generous in my review of it a couple of years ago, mainly because I recognize how beloved it is and, begrudgingly, what it does well. But I’m not going to waste more of my word-count shitting on Wicked except to declare that Pippin is, in my estimation, just a wildly more compelling show—more musically dynamic, more suited to the form, more genuinely fun—and this production is a solid, sensuous rendering.
Sorry not sorry, one more shot at Wicked: there is nothing, for me, in that show—which takes itself way too seriously even as it sugarcoats its darkness—that can match the infectious joy, the showiness, the earnest and grounded emotionality of Pippin. Schwartz, and book writers Roger O. Hirson and Bob Fosse, allow for a giddy, vaudevillian charm to carry the themes of self-discovery, ambition and the ultimate compromise inherent in the journey of life. I get so swept up in its genuinely stirring numbers. Take, for instance, the haunting, eerily seductive and satirical war-mongering religiosity of “Glory!”
The meta-theatrical premise here is that a troupe of medieval thespians, wrangled into submission by a tyrannical Lead Player (a deliciously sinister KC Martinez), have spent years performing this story of prince Pippin (Anthony Palermo)—ambitious, idealistic university graduate, trying to find his “Corner of the Sky” (a corny yet undeniably rousing “I Want” song that hints at the stirring strains and soaring imagery that will later define Schwartz’s juggernaut “Defying Gravity”). In the play-within-a-play structure, we understand that the Pippin actor (which Palermo embodies with firm intentionality and understated, guileless charisma) is new to the role, allowing him the opportunity to break from tradition and decide, for himself, how his story plays out—dismantling the narrative machinery and theatrical trappings of the heroic journey he’s been press-ganged into.
In his quest for fulfilment, Pippin tries being a solider in his father Charlemagne’s army (W. Joseph Matheson’s gruff, patriarchal persona here is hilariously endearing), has a bunch of sex, usurps his father as King, discovers leadership isn’t his bag, finds himself a father figure to a widow, Catherine (Krizia Natale) and her son, Theo (Max Goodman). Natale sells Catherine’s desperation and gumption (she, too, rebels against the Lead Player’s schematic oppression) with convincing sincerity. Goodman, who lands some hilariously jarring one-liners, is a suitably precocious youngster without being twee.
Daniela Bauer’s Fastrada (Pippin’s pushy, devious mom) and Tanner Hamlin’s Lewis (Pippin’s not-so-bright, militaristic brother with a flamboyant streak) bring some camp flair to Pippin’s plight. The committed ensemble (Kathryn Carter, Olivia Buchanan, Mauranda Nunes and Bryce Gowdy) give playful, vivid dimension to Meredith Shedden’s choreography, which riffs on the Fosse of it all without being too rigidly pastiche.
You know who really brings down the house here? Donna Garner’s vivacious Bertha (Pippin’s grandmother)—the spunky, bad-ass, unapologetically raunchy and exuberant liver of life. Her big number, “No Time at All,” is an uproarious life anthem and joyfully interactive delight. Its carpe diem ethos, its buoyant melody, its euphoric momentum—had me beaming with a lump in my throat the whole song!
Gosh, almost 600 words in and I haven’t even touched on the artful whimsy of director Olivia Daniels’ production. In her set and prop design Meredith Wolting establishes the theatrical artifice that defines the show’s whole self-aware deal. Spilling anarchically out from a proscenium, the faux-stonework arches, benches and statuary are both majestic and deliberately hokey. Hannah Dulong’s vibrant costumes, hair and makeup further the motif of medieval pageantry. Niall Durcan’s lighting adds rich and colourful dimension to the spectacle—until, of course, the show’s iconic finale, where the theatrical devices are ripped away in a deeply poignant portrait of mundane humanity.
There were, at opening, intermittent issues with the sound mix—most notably, a few ensemble numbers and the Lead Player’s lyrics were sometimes hard to make out. I’ve encountered this problem, though, in a lot of recent productions—both indie efforts and large-scale tours. Insufficient technical rehearsal? Perhaps this quirk will be smoothed out over the course of a run. This is somewhat less of a problematic distraction if you are already familiar with the material. And, honestly, though annoying, it wasn’t severe enough to significantly mar my experience of this lush, kinetic and heartfelt Pippin.


